BYU Content With Independence/WCC

There has been much anxiety and curiosity from the fans in regards to whether or not BYU was going to be the front-runner to join the Big XII conference. Some reports have said they were, while others have informed otherwise. More recently, the conference extended an invitation to former Mountain West Conference rival of BYU’s, TCU. The Horned Frogs accepted that invitation and will be a member starting in 2012.

That got the fans in an uproar. TCU joining was a near answer as to if the Cougars were headed into a BCS conference. There has been so much unsaid and unreported on the issue. Fans just want at least an explanation and feel they deserve it, which may be accurate.

Source after source has been cited all over the social media world. Nobody knows who to believe. I don’t enjoy using the term “source” lightly nor have I tweeted or written anything based off of a source I have … until now…

A major sponsor for the BYU athletics department has been in contact with Tom Holmoe, the athletic director at the Y, regarding this very topic. We all remember how insanely crazy the summer of 2010 was on the same topic of conference realignment and on September 1st, 2010, Holmoe and others made the announcement that BYU football would be leaving the Mountain West conference (MWC) and becoming an independent program while the other sports at BYU would join the West Coast Conference (WCC).

It was first reported BYU would be joining the WAC in all other sports, but Craig Thompson, the MWC commissioner made moves on his own and in result, not allowing BYU to join the WAC. This was a very hectic and busy process for Holmoe and the rest of personnel within the athletic department in Provo.

What this sponsor was able to gather, is that Holmoe and his personnel simply didn’t want to go through that same process two years in a row. Especially after gaining an eight year television contract with ESPN. It was hard work and currently the BYU athletics program is content with where they stand and have every intent on remaining where they are and fulfilling those contracts.

They also were hesitant to sever ties with the other religiously affiliated schools in the WCC before even competing within it. Some have reported that Holmoe tried to work a deal with the Big XII where BYU would be a football only member and keep the other sports in the WCC. I was not able to confirm or deny those reports.

Realignment is football driven and some have been worried about the Cougars outstanding basketball coach Dave Rose and how he has felt about the move from the MWC to the WCC. I’ve heard from some fans, “Rose belongs in a conference like the Big XII and will eventually move on to bigger and better things” and other similar statements. Let’s all just relax. Don’t forget at the end of this last basketball season Coach Rose was heavily swayed to coach elsewhere and chose to stay in Provo. Let that resolve some anxiety on the matter, though I have not spoken directly with Coach Rose nor has he addressed the issue publicly.

At this time, BYU has not made an official announcement or statement, nor has the Big XII as to what the concrete truth is. You would think if there was an offer it would have been known right?

As for the Big XII, they will only have 10 members in 2012 as they’ve publicly stated, though it’s well-known they intend on expanding to get back to a twelve school, two division league. So movement is only done for now. Perhaps the future of BYU being in the Big XII isn’t completely a dead hope for the fans. But as for right now, it will not be happening for the 2012 athletic season. But who one knows what the future holds?

Now let’s get back to the football season shall we?

Follow Chesh on twitter @CheshSports

About the author


Jimmie is the co-host of the J&J Podcast, a Documenter at DMBA, a single dad, and a singer/songwriter. His music can be found at his website Follow him on twitter @JimmieChesh. Follow the J&J Podcast on twitter @j_jpodcast.


Click here to post a comment
  • Nice write up Chesh. I appreciated the position you took of addressing the rumors and rumors of rumors as well as the “FWIW” with regards to sources. Bottom line is, there is a football season afoot and its time we pay attention to the team and not the athletic department.

    I believe Rose signed another extension this past off-season did he not? If so, I’m sure Holmoe will have made it difficult to leave and if he did, does that not “buy some time” with regards to getting him “where he belongs”, that is to say, a power conference?

    If that is the case, then we can just relax. The Big XII doesn’t seem to be in a hurry to move beyond ten, any offer from the Big East is just a ‘knee-jerk” reaction to the moving landscape of CFB.

    Lets just sit back and enjoy the second half of a season that is still yet to be defined. Here’s to an exciting and hopefully, similarly successful second half!

  • Do you guys seriously believe this crap? Tom Holmoe said no to the Big12 because he didn’t want to do the legwork? Yeah right.

    First, the legwork to make a single season’s independent schedule is likely to be far more than the effort required to arrange moving conferences.

    Next, taking this mentality would be extremely shortsighted, and would fly in the face of everything Holmoe has actually said ON THE RECORD about this. A few months back, in response to drivel posted by the homers at another notable BYU site, rumors started swirling, and Holmoe was interviewed. He said it would be stupid to stick their heads in the sand and that BYU would thoroughly examine ANY conference that came calling as a matter of policy, because they didn’t want to miss a better opportunity or find themselves left behind by the college football world. As recently as last week, Bronco Mendenhall went on the record saying that he would respect the admins decisions, but his opinion was that they should accept a BCS conference invite if one comes (he wasn’t specific to B12). Do you honestly think that Holmoe is speaking out of both sides of his mouth on this issue?

    Third, regardless of your ESPN contract, the money in the B12 simply dwarfs whatever you’re getting from ESPN. One of BYU’s major athletic goals is self sufficiency. To pass up double the money simply because you think you’re ESPN’s darling flies in the face of that goal.

    In order to believe this rumor, you have to believe that Tom Holmoe is a lazy hypocrite. It’s simply not believable.

    As for the truth of what happened, I spoke to my former Stake President 2 nights ago. He is a big named Ute booster (and by big, I mean there are numerous buildings on campus bearing his name), and is also a member of the quorum of the seventy, serving with numerous members of the BYU board of Trustees, and is also a close personal friend of Pres Samuelson. He told me that ALL of the rumors are outrageously overhyped. According to Samuelson and his BOT friends, the BOT never discussed the B12 in any form. They authorized Holmoe to have extremely preliminary conversations with conferences regarding membership as part of his duties as the AD of an independent school, but his authorization was limited to gauging interest and identifying if they would fit with BYU’s most basic requirements (no sunday play)… ANYTHING outside of the scope of those things would require BOT approval to proceed. Since they never had ANY conversations about joining the B12, it’s a safe bet that any talks that might have happened never went beyond that very preliminary stage.